3 Comments

Ban the Haka. Or at least move it.

I like the Haka, I think it brings an extra dimension to TV, but let’s have it at the end of the match, not at the beginning. The dance now performed isn’t even the traditional Maori form.

The All Blacks do obtain significant biological advantages at the beginning of each game from performing the Haka. From a physiological standpoint, all the shouting and posturing the Haka brings with it causes enhanced levels of adrenalin and testosterone to be released into the blood stream. These in turn boost Oxygen and energy levels in the blood and muscles, warming the body up generally, and making it ready for action in a biological sense that any team that has to stand and watch, quietly, without moving, are completely deprived of. Even worse, the fight or flight responses of the non-performers produce different hormones, ones that a boxer would recognise before entering a fight he fears he will lose and one which so many battle displays are designed to create in one’s opponent. Not for nothing are war cries used even today by modern armies and soldiers.

There is also a psychological component, but this can be managed to a large degree through the use of mind control techniques. The main effect is the same as taking an injection of chemicals just before a match begins. It could be argued that it is cheating.

Are the All Blacks so insecure about their playing abilities that they can’t play without this extra advantage? Or do they know it gives them an extra boost just before kick off that helps them score first, thus changing the flavour of the rest of the game so the opposing team is always fighting an uphill battle?

Traditionally, most Rugby matches at club level end up with both teams’ players having beers together in the clubhouse until the early hours. Performing the Haka at the end of the match would then be seen as a real welcome, more akin with the traditional origins which have somehow been lost in the modern form. Remember, to a Maori the Haka is traditionally not a war dance performed before physical battle, but it is a welcome dance performed before two groups socialise together, a challenge to identify any warlike intentions the “foreigners” may harbour. Moving the dance to the end of the match would also show respect for winners or losers – winners because they played well, losers because they gained the respect of the victors through the character and nature of the way they played.

That would meld together the two traditions, the Maori and the Rugby joined as one. Leaving it as it is only gives the team who perform it an unfair advantage. Rugby isn’t supposed to be like that.

Advertisements

3 comments on “Ban the Haka. Or at least move it.

  1. […] Decade has written that the Haka performed by the All Blacks before every game should either be banned or moved to the end of the 80 minutes. He argues, quite forcibly, that the tradition “biologically” boosts the New Zealand […]

  2. Well, any country can have a haka-like war dance if they want one. Many other Pacific nations (Fiji, Samoa, Tonga etc)have war dances and South Africa was thinking about bringing in their own. Their are advantages, which could also be seen as unfair, but it is still part of their culture, even if it is not the original Maori dance. It wouldn’t work as well at the en of the dance, the whole idea is to scare the ‘enemy’ beforehand. Anyway, this is just my my opinion.
    **Also, I’m not just defending the haka because I’m from New Zealand. I’m not.

  3. I’m glad to see you agree with me – you have described the effect of the Haka almost completely. In Rugby terms though, it has been used to give the All Blacks an unfair advantage, and that’s not Rugby.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: